I’m unbearably close to having this working. I found the problem that I described yesterday. I was using soft interrupts to have UnixIO signal event readiness. As far as I can tell, the interrupt handler is called more-or-less directly by whoever triggered the interrupt, meaning that the my handler was running in the UnixIO select loop task. My handler calls back into UnixIO after the last write is done to disable write events. I’m not exactly sure, but I think I understand - UnixIO isn’t reentrant, and so the lists got corrupted.
So that was a bit annoying, as it seemed so close, but I had to backpedal. The answer is to switch from soft interrupts to signals, but using signals requires that I have a task to signal, so I reworked the code to have TAP IO handled by a separate task. It sits and waits for UnixIO to poke it, and then reads or writes as appropriate. It took me ages to get it going, mostly because I spent two hours tracking down a stupid crasher that resulted from my own inability to read.
This morning I finally got it working (for some value of working). It successfully responded to three packets, the initial ARP request and two ICMP ECHOes (ie pings), before hanging. The last thing I had chance to check before getting to work was to see where the hang is. Its stuck somewhere in
timer.device, called from AROSTCP, looping over a list that points back into itself. I’m not quite sure yet how to track this one down. I figure it’ll be me not setting some value properly in one of the AROSTCP requests, or more likely, not locking something properly before changing it. Horrible horrible problems in both cases. I’m not sure how I’m going to find it, but I’m sure I’ll think of something.
I just wish it would work. Its kinda demoralising - its been almost working for three days now, but just not quite. A few people have asked about it, so there’s instant glory as soon as I’m done, which I want now :P
It certainly is a wonderful way of learning the system though. I know this for certain - UnixIO is a great concept, but the code is horribly crusty and disgusting. It needs quite a bit of work, which I might do sometime (ie added to TODO list).